Analyzing the Sustainability of Russia’s Growing Economy

Russia’s Full-Scale Invasion of Ukraine: An Economic Impact Analysis

Russia’s comprehensive invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 sparked global outrage and led to a wave of sanctions aimed at crippling the Kremlin’s war capabilities. These measures targeted Russia’s assets abroad, cut its economy off from the global financial system, and aimed at its energy exports.

Initially, Western officials described the sanctions as “crippling,” “debilitating,” and “unprecedented.” Such strong language created an impression that Russia’s economy would inevitably collapse under the pressure, forcing the Kremlin to withdraw its troops.

However, 27 months later, the conflict continues unabated. Contrary to expectations, Russia’s economy is growing. The International Monetary Fund forecasts a 3.2% growth for Russia this year, outpacing many advanced economies. Despite the “debilitating” sanctions, Russian supermarkets remain stocked, though prices have risen and some Western products have disappeared due to companies exiting the Russian market in protest.

Yet, many Western products still reach Russia through indirect routes, and American cola can still be found in stores. While European and American CEOs no longer attend Russia’s annual St Petersburg International Economic Forum in large numbers, delegates from over 130 countries participated this year, underscoring Russia’s new economic alliances with the East and the Global South.

Russian officials boast that attempts to politically and economically isolate the country have failed. Yevgeny Nadorshin, senior economist at PF Capital, noted that while sanctions disrupted the economy, it has largely adapted and restored functionality.

Does this mean the sanctions have failed? Elina Ribakova, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, argues that sanctions are not a switch to make a country disappear. Instead, they disrupt temporarily until the affected nation finds workarounds, as Russia has done. Moscow has redirected its oil exports from Europe to China and India. The G7 and EU’s December 2022 price cap plan to limit Russia’s oil revenue to below $60 a barrel has been circumvented easily by Russia.

The dilemma for the US and its partners is that, while aiming to reduce Russia’s revenue, they also want to avoid hiking global energy prices by keeping Russian oil flowing. Consequently, Russia continues to earn significant revenue, fueling its war efforts.

China has emerged as Russia’s economic lifeline, becoming its largest oil supplier and a major trading partner. Trade between the two countries reached a record $240 billion last year. In Russian cities like St Petersburg and Moscow, Chinese electronics and automobiles dominate the market. Russia’s new Volga car is even based on a Chinese model, highlighting the shift in manufacturing dependencies.

Military spending has been a significant driver of Russia’s economic growth since the invasion began. Armaments factories are operating around the clock, and more Russians are employed in the defense sector, driving up wages. However, this focus on military expenditure comes at the expense of other sectors. Chris Weafer, founding partner of Macro-Advisory, warns that diverting funds from infrastructure and development projects to the military could destroy the economy in the long term.

While Russia has managed to adapt to the sanctions, the US is now threatening secondary sanctions on foreign banks aiding Russian transactions, creating new financial challenges. According to Chris Weafer, accessing spare parts and maintaining international transactions have become increasingly difficult, potentially leading to a financial crisis by autumn.

Thus, it would be premature to conclude that Russia has overcome the sanctions. Although it has found ways to mitigate their impact, the pressure on its economy remains significant.

BBC InDepth is your source for comprehensive analysis and expert insights from top journalists. We offer fresh perspectives and deep reporting on major issues to help you navigate a complex world. Stay tuned for thought-provoking content across BBC Sounds and iPlayer. Share your feedback with us to help shape our future content.